Welcome Chris,
I would agree that you are not in the best signal area.
Given the fact you have low band VHF, high band VHF
and UHF as well, one of your best alternatives would
be:
http://www.homedepot.com/p/Channel-Master-
Suburban-Advantage-45-Mile-Range-Outdoor-Antenna
-CM-3016/203763042
The antenna is compact, inexpensive and works fairly
well. You should use an outdoor mount, as far away
from trees as possible while keeping the cable to your
television under 50 feet, if possible. RG6 is the best
cable to use, by far. Hope this helps.