I just wanted to post a follow up to this topic. I appreciate the suggestions Tigerbangs, but I wanted to avoid two antennas so I ended up with an
RCA ANT751. For my situation with line of sight and 35 miles to the transmitters, this small antenna does a fantastic job. My UHF stations are coming in just as strong as before and my VHF stations are now just slightly less strong than the UHF stations. For anyone else in a similar situation, I would whole heartedly recommend this antenna. I'll look into the distribution amp suggestion when I start to distribute this to more TVs.