TV Fool

TV Fool (http://forum.tvfool.com/index.php)
-   Help With Reception (http://forum.tvfool.com/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Antenna Suggestion in Charlotte (28214) (http://forum.tvfool.com/showthread.php?t=15543)

shoman94 13-Jan-2016 8:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bebo189 (Post 54246)
What would be the advantage of going with a distribution amp with a 4 way splitter if I only need 2 outputs?

Future... If you ever decide to add a TV and it's 7.5db gain on each output.

ADTech 13-Jan-2016 8:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shoman94 (Post 54248)
Future... If you ever decide to add a TV and it's 7.5db gain on each output.

Actually, it's ~15 dB gain with ~7-8 dB insertion loss per port. The net gain is around 7.5 dB for a typical four-port distribution amp with a 15-16 dB amp at its input.

All consumer distribution amps with multiple outputs follow the same scheme. One amp, followed by no splitter, a two-port, a four-port, eight-port, etc. Each time the signal is split in half, an insertion loss of 3.5-4 dB is incurred.

shoman94 13-Jan-2016 9:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADTech (Post 54249)
Actually, it's ~15 dB gain with ~7-8 dB insertion loss per port. The net gain is around 7.5 dB for a typical four-port distribution amp with a 15-16 dB amp at its input.

All consumer distribution amps with multiple outputs follow the same scheme. One amp, followed by no splitter, a two-port, a four-port, eight-port, etc. Each time the signal is split in half, an insertion loss of 3.5-4 dB is incurred.

Your site specifically states 7.5db gain per port. I guess I was misinformed.

ADTech 13-Jan-2016 10:30 PM

Not misinformed, just under-informed. ;)

Things on the website are often greatly simplified....

shoman94 13-Jan-2016 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADTech (Post 54252)
Not misinformed, just under-informed. ;)

Things on the website are often greatly simplified....


"7.5 dB Gain per port"

So when I read this it doesn't mean what it says?:confused::confused::confused:

rabbit73 13-Jan-2016 11:59 PM

It means what it says, but it is a simplification.

Using the Channel Master series as another example for comparison of specs:

3410
A one port distribution amp does not contain a splitter, so its gain is 15 dB.
http://www.channelmaster.com/Antenna..._p/cm-3410.htm

3412
A 2-port distribution amp contains an amp with a gain of 15 dB and a 2-way splitter with a loss of 3.5 dB per port, for a NET gain of 11.5 dB per port.
http://www.channelmaster.com/Antenna..._p/cm-3412.htm

3414
A 4-port distribution amp contains an amp with a gain of 15 dB and a 4-way splitter with a loss of 7 dB per port, for a NET gain of 8 dB per port.
http://www.channelmaster.com/Antenna..._p/cm-3414.htm

Just to male it even more confusing, PCT International not only makes the CM distribution amps with the stupid hard-to-read black labels, they also make the mini drop passive return CATV amps with white labels that are equivalent.
http://www.pctstore.com/RF_Amplifier...fiers_s/58.htm

bebo189 20-Jan-2016 5:37 PM

OK, bought the CM3412 and hooked up one of the outputs to the TV upstairs and then switched it to the TV downstairs. It added a few more channels (33 total, up from 21 or so) to the upstairs TV. It also added a few more to the TV downstairs (18 total up from 8 or so). I'm wondering why there could still be such a discrepancy. Is it possible that some of the cabling being used on the downstairs route is not up to snuff? Any ideas?

rabbit73 20-Jan-2016 6:18 PM

Which direction did you pick for the 4221, 260 or 115?

Where is the 3412 located, near the antenna or further downstream?

Tell us how long the cable runs are starting at the antenna, then down to the splitter or 3412, then to each TV. Is it like this?

Code:

                          coax 20 ft > 2nd floor TV
                          /
4221 > coax 50 ft > 3412 > 
                          \
                          coax 60 ft > 1st floor TV

Give us a list of channels at each TV; it does sound like the 3412 made an improvement.

Quote:

Is it possible that some of the cabling being used on the downstairs route is not up to snuff?
Yes. It is also possible that there is a hidden splitter or defect on that run. You can check that by running a temporary length of known good coax downstairs.

Do you have any way to measure the signal strength with one of your TVs?

bebo189 20-Jan-2016 8:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54354)
Which direction did you pick for the 4221, 260 or 115?

I tried 260 first, then 115 (current direction and the setup used to pickup # of channels listed in my previous post).

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54354)
Where is the 3412 located, near the antenna or further downstream?

3412 is right off of the antenna (maybe 6 feet of cable away at most).

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54354)
Tell us how long the cable runs are starting at the antenna, then down to the splitter or 3412, then to each TV. Is it like this?

Code:

                          coax 20 ft > 2nd floor TV
                          /
4221 > coax 6 ft > 3412 > 
                          \
                          coax 60 ft > 1st floor TV


Very similar, I'd say it's closer to this:

Code:

                          coax 50 ft > cable extension adapter male-to-male (in junction box) > coax 20 ft (guess) > 2nd floor coax wall jack > coax 6 ft> 2nd floor TV
                          /
4221 > coax 6 ft > 3412 > 
                          \
                          coax 50 ft > cable extension adapter male-to-male (in junction box) > coax 60 ft (guess) > 1st floor coax wall jack> coax 25 ft (through wall) > 1st floor TV

Note: Up to this point, I have not had both 3412 outputs hooked up to both paths. I have been switching between paths where the coax 50 ft enters the junction box. After I verify that I can get all the channels I want on the downstairs TV, I plan to run the extra 50 ft coax and truly split the signal to both paths.

Also, is it possible that the 25 feet of coax cable that I run through the wall on the 1st floor to the TV would degrade the signal if it weren't 75 ohm quad shielded? I read somewhere that this was important. I bought this years ago, and I'm not sure if it is 75 ohm quad shielded or not.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54354)
Give us a list of channels at each TV; it does sound like the 3412 made an improvement.

I will pull the list when I get home for both TVs.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54354)
Do you have any way to measure the signal strength with one of your TVs?

I tried looking for this option on my 1st floor TV, but couldn't find anything after experimenting or googling the TV. My TVs are listed below. Maybe someone can help me locate a way to check it.
  • Vizio M552I-B2 (1st floor TV)
  • LG 42LD550 (2nd floor TV)

bebo189 21-Jan-2016 1:20 AM

Here's the channels I get on each of the TVs. Each TV has it's own tab. On the 2nd floor TV, the channels highlighted in green are ones that the 1st floor TV doesn't pick up.

rabbit73 21-Jan-2016 2:15 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Code:

                    50' > F81 > 20' > F81 > 6' > 2nd Fl
                    /
4221 > 50ft > 3412 > 
                    \
                    50' > F81 > 60' > F81 > 25' >1st Fl

50 + 20 + 6 = 76 ft
50 + 60 + 25 = 135 ft
difference of 59 ft; about 3 dB for UHF,
approx. the same as a 2-way splitter loss

So if you inserted a 2-way splitter in the 2nd floor line after the 3412, the 2 TVs should be getting about the same signal strength. If not, there is another loss that exists in the 1st Floor line.
Quote:

Also, is it possible that the 25 feet of coax cable that I run through the wall on the 1st floor to the TV would degrade the signal if it weren't 75 ohm quad shielded? I read somewhere that this was important. I bought this years ago, and I'm not sure if it is 75 ohm quad shielded or not.
The attenuation loss is about the same for regular coax as it is for quad. The quad has an extra layer of shield to reduce pickup of interference; you don't need it for most applications.

Do you have AC power for the 3412 in the attic?

Quote:

Vizio M552I-B2 (1st floor TV)
LG 42LD550 (2nd floor TV)
LG 42LD550
http://www.lg.com/us/support-product/lg-42LD550
When selecting DTV or Cable DTV input signal in Manual Tuning, you can view the on-screen signal strength monitor to see the quality of the signal being received.

http://forum.tvfool.com/attachment.p...4&d=1453348228

I'm having trouble downloading your Google doc of channels. I think I would need to log on before it would allow my me to download it; I have had this trouble before.

rabbit73 21-Jan-2016 11:20 PM

1 Attachment(s)
OK, got your 1st Floor list using View Only at Google Docs. A lot of signals coming in the back of the antenna.

http://forum.tvfool.com/attachment.p...5&d=1453422015

rabbit73 22-Jan-2016 12:41 AM

1 Attachment(s)
And the 2nd Floor
http://www.rabbitears.info/search.ph...pe=dBm&height=
click on callsign to see networks

http://forum.tvfool.com/attachment.p...6&d=1453426856

bebo189 26-Jan-2016 12:34 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Sorry, it's taken me so long to respond.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54363)
Do you have AC power for the 3412 in the attic?

Yes, I have the 3412 plugged into an outlet in the attic using the AC adapter that came with the 3412. The AC adapter is connected to the unit via a coax cable.

I went ahead and used the instructions you posted to get the signal strength/signal quality readings for each channel on the LG 42LD550 (2nd Story TV). Here they are:

http://forum.tvfool.com/attachment.p...3&d=1453771288

Reminder: Green is channels I get on the 2nd Floor TV but not on the 1st Floor TV. Bolded Channels are the ones that I actually WANT to get on both TVs.

I am not sure what the difference is between "Signal Strength" and "Signal Qualtiy" as called out on my LG 42LD550 TV.

Also, the weird thing to me is that is that the main channels that I want to get on the 1st Floor TV, but only get on the 2nd Floor TV (WSOC-TV, WTVI-HD, WTVI-MV, WTVI-Ct) all have "Signal Strengths" on the 2nd Floor TV of 89% or higher. In fact, there are stations that I got on both TVs, for which the signal strength on the 2nd Floor TV is lower than 89%. Doesn't really make any sense to me.

Also, can you confirm that "front" and "back" of antenna is as I think in the picture below?

http://forum.tvfool.com/attachment.p...1&d=1453771974

rabbit73 26-Jan-2016 12:51 AM

Quote:

Sorry, it's taken me so long to respond.
No problem; it takes time to do it right. And it's going to take time for us to digest your results and think of an intelligent helpful comment.:)
Quote:

I am not sure what the difference is between "Signal Strength" and "Signal Qualtiy" as called out on my LG 42LD550 TV.
Every manufacturer does it a little differently. The percent scale is only relative, not absolute, but it is very useful for comparisons. The signal strength is similar to the NM dB or Signal pwr dBm scales on your tvfool report. The Signal Quality is probably SNR (Signal to Noise Ratio).
Quote:

Also, can you confirm that "front" and "back" of antenna is as I think in the picture below?
Your labels are correct.
Quote:

Also, the weird thing to me is that is that the main channels that I want to get on the 1st Floor TV, but only get on the 2nd Floor TV (WSOC-TV, WTVI-HD, WTVI-MV, WTVI-Ct) all have "Signal Strengths" on the 2nd Floor TV of 89% or higher. In fact, there are stations that I got on both TVs, for which the signal strength on the 2nd Floor TV is lower than 89%. Doesn't really make any sense to me.
It doesn't make sense yet to me either.

There are three possibilities. The loss in the coax line to the first floor is more than estimated. As a test, run a temporary coax line to the 1st floor to bypass the in-wall coax run.

The 1st floor tuner is more sensitive to overload than the tuner in the 2nd floor TV. Try inserting various values of attenuation between the antenna and the input of the 3412. A 2-way splitter has a loss of 3.5 dB, a 4-way 7 dB.
https://www.antennasdirect.com/store...ttenuator.html
http://www.3starinc.com/drop_in-line_attenuator.html
http://mjsales.net/collections/atten...ant=1083705673
•Attenuation values 1, 3, 6, 8, 10, 12, 16, 20dB (FAM)
click on 1 dB for other values; the up and down arrows are faint

The tuner in the 1st floor TV is less sensitive than the tuner in the 2nd floor TV. To test this theory you would need to move the 2nd floor TV down to the 1st floor.

Is it safe for me to assume that you do a tuner rescan of the 1st floor TV after a change?

bebo189 26-Jan-2016 5:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54419)
Every manufacturer does it a little differently. The percent scale is only relative, not absolute, but it is very useful for comparisons. The signal strength is similar to the NM dB or Signal pwr dBm scales on your tvfool report. The Signal Quality is probably SNR (Signal to Noise Ratio).

For "Signal Quality", I assume 100% is the ideal? Almost every station was at that value, so it looks like I don't have any signal quality issues.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54419)
It doesn't make sense yet to me either.

There are three possibilities. The loss in the coax line to the first floor is more than estimated. As a test, run a temporary coax line to the 1st floor to bypass the in-wall coax run.

My observation below would seem to cast some doubt on the first possibility, wouldn't it?

Quote:

...main channels that I want to get on the 1st Floor TV, but only get on the 2nd Floor TV (WSOC-TV, WTVI-HD, WTVI-MV, WTVI-Ct) all have "Signal Strengths" on the 2nd Floor TV of 89% or higher. In fact, there are stations that I got on both TVs, for which the signal strength on the 2nd Floor TV is lower than 89%."

I will have to look into the other 2 possibilities. Finding a cable long enough, or a short enough path for my existing coax could be an issue. I could possibly run from the antenna straight to the wall the 1st Floor TV is mounted to, but I'm guessing I'd run into some 2X4s going down 2 stories. If only I could get signal strength readings from the 1st Floor TV.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rabbit73 (Post 54419)
Is it safe for me to assume that you do a tuner rescan of the 1st floor TV after a change?

Yes.


All times are GMT. The time now is 4:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright © TV Fool, LLC