Okay we are cutting Direct TV 9-14-2019, everyone's replies were greatly appreciated.
I can analyze anything beyond my understanding as I am quite OCD, so my obsessive behavior disorder acknowledged I am down to Four antennas.
As already mentioned by Ground Ur Mast the:
Winegard 8200U
Channel Master Advantage 100
Solid Signal Extreme Signal HD8200XL
Channel Master CM3020 deepest fringe
Provided performance is fairly equal then craftsmanship and durability would be the next concern.
Any further advice or should I just draw straws ? LOL
As always thanks and cheers, Tony